| 1958 Little 500 Results | |||
| Place | Team | Laps | Time |
| 1 | Phi Kappa Psi | 200 | 2:17:23 |
| 2 | Sigma Nu | ||
| 3 | Phi Gamma Delta | ||
| 4 | Delta Upsilon | ||
| 5 | Sigma Alpha Epsilon | ||
| 6 | West Hall II | ||
| 7 | South Cottage Grove | ||
| 8 | Phi Delta Theta | ||
| 9 | Acacia | ||
| 10 | Sigma Pi | ||
| 11 | Chi Phi | ||
| 12 | Alpha Tau Omega | ||
| 13 | Tau Kappa Epsilon | ||
| 14 | South Hall Buccaneers | ||
| 15 | Delta Chi | ||
| 16 | Beta Theta Pi | ||
| 171 | Dodds House | ||
| 18 | Rollins House | ||
| 19 | Kappa Delta Rho | ||
| 20 | Ferguson House | ||
| 21 | North Hall Barons | ||
| 22 | Delta Tau Delta | ||
| 23 | Hickory Hall West | ||
| 24 | Kappa Kappa Psi | ||
| 25 | Kappa Sigma | ||
| 26 | Lambda Chi Alpha | ||
| 27 | Sigma Alpha Mu | ||
| 28 | Rogers V | ||
| 29 | Harding House | ||
| 30 | Zeta Beta Tau | ||
| 31 | Hall House | ||
| 32 | Laurel House | ||
| 33 | Ruter House | ||